Random in Death by J D Robb, aka Nora Roberts, a book review of the NYT Bestseller novel

Posted in: Novels
Random in Death by J D Robb novel book review ReadByCritics

“Random in Death” emerges as the latest jewel in the crown of J D Robb, the pseudonymous identity of the acclaimed author Nora Roberts, renowned for her literary prowess. Nestled within the captivating In Death series, this futuristic police procedural plunges readers into the heart of a tumultuous New York City, shadowed by Lieutenant Eve Dallas’s relentless pursuit of justice amidst a series of seemingly arbitrary murders.

Summary of the Novel:
The narrative unfurls with the tragic demise of Jenna Harbough, a young girl discovered lifeless in an alley, a victim of a lethal cocktail of drugs. As the body count escalates, Lieutenant Eve Dallas and her dedicated team embark on a race against time to decipher the cryptic motives behind the seemingly random killings. A tapestry of secrets and lies unravels, prompting the question of whether there’s a more sinister design orchestrating the chaos.

Important Characters:
At the helm of the story is Lieutenant Eve Dallas, a tenacious detective grappling with the shadows of her own troubled past. Roarke, her husband, a mysterious and affluent businessman, plays a pivotal role in the intricate web of the narrative. Supporting Eve are Peabody, her loyal and industrious partner, and Dr. Mira, a forensic psychologist providing invaluable insights into the psyche of the elusive killer.

The Writing Style of the Author:
J.D. Robb, in her distinctive style, crafts a narrative that is both rapid-paced and immersive. With an unwavering focus on character development and intricate plotting, she skillfully interlaces multiple storylines, delivering a reading experience that is both rich and captivating. The infusion of futuristic technology and settings amplifies the intrigue, bestowing upon the narrative a unique and exhilarating dimension.

For enthusiasts captivated by the allure of “Random in Death,” a trove of literary treasures awaits within the In Death series. Works such as “Naked in Death,” “Glory in Death,” and “Immortal in Death” promise a continuation of Robb’s signature style, featuring the same dynamic narrative pace, complex character portrayals, and a futuristic backdrop that defines “Random in Death.”

The Reception:
The reception accorded to “Random in Death” has been nothing short of accolades from readers who laud the novel’s riveting plot and engaging characters. The seamless fusion of mystery, suspense, and science fiction elements within the narrative has garnered praise for creating an enthralling and distinctive reading experience.

Critical Opinions:
Critical acclaim has also flowed towards “Random in Death,” with pundits extolling the novel’s tightly woven plot and well-sculpted characters. Comparisons with other luminaries of the mystery and suspense genre, including Michael Connelly and John Grisham, have been drawn by discerning critics, highlighting the novel’s standing among contemporary works of similar ilk.

Well, well, well! Nothing is perfect, as you must be aware of already! As an avid reader immersed in J D Robb’s In Death series, delving into “Random in Death” was both a nostalgic reunion and a journey into uncharted waters. However, the experience, though peppered with the familiar cadence of Lieutenant Eve Dallas’s investigative prowess, encountered a few turbulent currents. The plot, regrettably, sailed through somewhat repetitive channels, mirroring echoes of past narratives. The lack of originality left a discernible imprint, causing the storyline to feel disappointingly predictable, a sentiment shared by fellow readers who, like me, have traversed the series landscape.

Characters, the lifeblood of the In Death series, encountered a snag in their evolution. While Eve Dallas and her ensemble cast are old acquaintances, some characters in “Random in Death” appeared underdeveloped, akin to mere sketches rather than fully fleshed-out personas. It was as if certain individuals lingered in the shadows, never stepping into the spotlight long enough for readers to form a meaningful connection. This, for someone invested in the intricate web of relationships woven across previous novels, felt like a missed opportunity to deepen our understanding of these familiar faces.

The emotional pulse, a hallmark of J D Robb’s storytelling, seemed somewhat faint in “Random in Death.” As the investigation unfolded, the procedural aspects dominated the narrative, leaving the emotional aftermath relegated to the periphery. The profound impact of events on the characters, a poignant thread that has resonated in earlier works, was regrettably muted. This emotional resonance has been the soul of the series, and its subdued presence left a void that many, myself included, found palpable.

Dialogue, a vital instrument in character portrayal, faltered in its authenticity. Some exchanges felt contrived, with characters’ conversations at times veering into stilted and unnatural territory. For a series that thrives on the chemistry and camaraderie between characters, the dialogue’s lack of genuine authenticity created moments of disconnect, hindering the overall immersion into the narrative.

The pacing, akin to a vessel navigating unpredictable currents, encountered its fair share of challenges. While certain sections raced with breakneck speed, others languished in a slow ebb. The uneven pacing disrupted the narrative flow, hindering the creation of a consistently engaging and suspenseful reading experience. This pacing hiccup, especially for those accustomed to the series’ trademark rhythm, became a notable detour in an otherwise familiar literary journey.

In navigating the multifaceted realm of “Random in Death,” it becomes apparent that, like any expansive series, it grapples with the delicate balance of maintaining thematic consistency while introducing fresh elements. While the flaws encountered might be seen as a temporary squall in the expansive ocean of J D Robb’s In Death series, they underscore the challenge of sustaining momentum and originality across a long-running narrative. As an ardent follower, I remain hopeful that subsequent entries will navigate these literary waters with renewed vigour, recapturing the essence that has made the series a cherished companion on the literary seas.

In summation, “Random in Death” stands as a gripping and suspense-laden testament to J D Robb’s narrative prowess. The intricate characters, fast-paced writing style, and beguiling plot converge to create a literary masterpiece that is destined to keep readers on the edge of their seats. For aficionados of mystery, suspense, and science fiction, this novel is an indispensable addition to the literary repertoire. Robb, under the guise of Nora Roberts, continues to be a luminary in the realm of gripping storytelling, leaving an indelible mark on the genre. As readers traverse the labyrinth of “Random in Death,” they are not merely observers but active participants in an enthralling journey through the intricacies of crime, justice, and the indomitable human spirit.


Click here to get a copy from Amazon India


Review by Manish for Read by Critics

Random in Death by J D Robb, aka Nora Roberts, a book review of the NYT Bestseller novel
  • Critical Rating


“Random in Death” may stumble in its repetitive plot and underdeveloped characters, but J.D. Robb’s gripping storytelling, rich with procedural intricacies and a futuristic edge, still ensures an engaging voyage for fans of the In Death series.

Read more posts in:

You will also enjoy reading:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed